IT EN About Eunomia
EU·nomia

Dispatches from the Europe that could have been.

Turning point: 2005 ›

Italian edition · · Year XXI of the Union · declared fiction

‹ Front page

A dispatch from the Europe that could have been. Turning point: 2005.

Dispatches from the Europe of 2005 ›

Economy · Paris

Flight delayed three hours: the refund arrives on its own. The new rule changes little, and that is the point

Read in:ItalianoEnglish
A bright airport gate on a morning, travellers seated with luggage, large windows and warm light, a calm atmosphere.
Departure lounge, weekday morning. The delay is an inconvenience, not a legal case.

This week’s vote confirmed the three-hour threshold for compensation, sped up refund timelines, and made the seat next to parents free for children. It was reported for what it is: a refinement. The substance was already there, and has been for twenty years.

I had the proof on Thursday, in person, on a Paris-Lisbon flight that departed three hours and ten minutes late. I filled in nothing. Friday morning the airline wrote to me unprompted, with the figure already calculated and the transfer date. This is how it works in the branch: the burden is on the carrier, not the passenger. I do not have to prove the harm, chase a form, or threaten a lawsuit for a sum worth less than the lawyer. The airline has to explain why it might not pay; I do not have to beg for it to pay. That inversion is the whole thing.

Shifting who carries the burden of proof looks like a detail for lawyers. It is, in fact, all the difference. Where the burden falls on the customer, the right exists on paper and dies in practice, because almost nobody has time to chase thirty euros. Where it falls on the company, the right happens by itself, automatically, even for people who do not know they have it. European law, since 2005, has systematically chosen the second path, and this week’s update simply restates the choice.

It is not a traveller’s paradise. The flight left late, I missed dinner with my sister, and no bank transfer gives that back. The system refunds the ticket, not the evening. But it does so without me lifting a finger, and described to someone who lives where a refund is a treasure hunt, that sounds like science fiction. Here it is just Tuesday.